One of the ways the world has advanced is by dividing up areas of knowledge into departments or specializations. We distinguish physics from chemistry and both of them from biology. We recognize psychology as different from sociology and economics as different from political science. This makes it hard for experts in one area to communicate with experts in another. On the other hand, it also makes it possible for there to be experts in the first place. There is so much knowledge in the world that one individual cannot comprehend it all. Indeed, even within recognized sciences, there are numerous subdivisions, as in biology between zoology and botany, and also between those who study ecosystems, those who study organism, those who study cells, and those who study DNA.
How did this all begin?
I would like to introduce Aristotle as the original father, not of science per se, but of the sciences.
He was, perhaps, the last individual who dabbled in the wide field of science and made contributions to almost all of those he engaged with. But he also saw the need of separating one area of study from another, recognizing similarities between some areas of study, but also acknowledging factors which divided them.
Aristotle was himself perhaps the greatest polymath of history. He did not just dabble in different areas, he immersed himself in them and transformed them. Here I just want to list the more important areas of study he himself explored, and in many cases named and distinguished, and all of which he investigated in some depth and made significant contributions to.
- Informal logic. Philosophers and sophists (the itinerant professors of the second half of the fifth century BCE) recognized logical inferences and logical fallacies, but no one, as far as we know, studied everyday logic systematically until Aristotle, whose Topics offer an extensive treatment of informal logic.
- Formal logic. Not satisfied with informal logic, Aristotle developed a systematic approach to logic, with the syllogism, consisting of two premises and a conclusion, complete with inference rules. His Prior Analytics presents the first system of logic, which dominated the philosophical world until the nineteenth century CE.
- Philosophy of Science. Plato, notably, had important things to say about natural science, as he departed from the view of his mentor, Socrates, who took no interest in the subject. But Plato’s remarks often come in dialogues focusing on things other than science (for instance the Phaedo, the Republic). He does offer one study of science, the Timaeus, but this is more a science treatise than a philosophy of science. It is Aristotle, in the Posterior Analytics, who makes a systematic study of science, distinguishing induction and deduction, axioms and theorems, principles and evidence.
- Physics. The very word ‘physics’ is derived from the subject of Aristotle’s Physics, ta physika, dealing with natural motion. Aristotle distinguishes natural motion from forced motion, the former happening “by nature,” the latter by some non-natural effort, as a a stone thrown by a huma travels forward by imposed force but falls to earth by nature. Aristotle introduces his four causes, argues against Parmenides and the Eleatics for saying there is no motion, and studies time, space, and motion. No one before him had studied natural motion in its own right.
- Astronomy and cosmology. The Presocratic philosophers had, for the most part, studied cosmogony and cosmology. Aristotle, however, makes a clear distinction between atmospheric phenomena (meteora) and heavenly phenomena (astronomy), which he studies in On the Heavens. In the wake of Eudoxus and Callippus, he develops a mathematical model of heavenly motions (Metaphysics XII.7) that came to dominate ancient theories.
- Meteorology. In his treatise Meteorologica, Aristotle studies atmospheric phenomena, including weather, oceanography, and earthquakes (which for him have an atmospheric component). His treatise is the most detailed account we have of ancient meteorology (books I-III). The fourth book of the treatise is a nascent study of chemistry.
- Biology. A number of Aristotle’s predecessors had studied biology in some way or another. But Aristotle, in the tradition of some medical schools (his father was a physician), performed and made his students perform, dissections of animals. He collected specimens, notably in the lagoon of Lesbos, studied many animal species, making numerous observations. His own focus was on zoology, while his colleague Theophrastus focused on botany. Aristotle wrote three lengthy treatises on zoology. In them, he reported observations of others, some of which were not confirmed until the nineteenth century of our era.
- Psychology. In his treatise On the Soul, Aristotle collects the theories of his predecessors on psychic phenomena, develops his own principles, and applies them to the natural world, studying not only human psychology but that of plants (basic functions such as nutrition and reproduction), lower animals (including sensation and locomotion). Humans have minds with higher cognitive functions. His treatise reads in many ways like a modern psychology textbook and sets out psychology as a separate area of study for the first time.
- Ethics. The topic of ethics was not one that exercised early Greek philosophers. Not until Democritus, a contemporary of Socrates, did any philosopher spend much time discussing morality. Socrates himself made moral philosophy his chief, and indeed, only concern, and called on his fellow citizens to make it their chief concern also. Socrates’ follower Plato portrayed Socrates in his discussions focusing on virtue. Plato expanded Socratic philosophy to include a theory of knowledge (epistemology), reality (metaphysics), and politics, among other things. But Plato never really separated the various aspects of philosophy, often combining all of them in his dialogues, such as the Phaedo and the Republic. Aristotle, however, taught courses on the theory of morality, ethics, separate from other areas of philosophy. In fact he taught two lecture course, known as the Eudemian Ethics and the Nicomachean Ethics, presumably presenting an earlier version and a later version of his ethical theory. Socrates, we may say, invented the study of ethics, but Aristotle made it a special study in its own right.
- Political Science. The rise of the sophistic movement coincided, probably not by accident, with the rise of democracy. The new form of government offered opportunities for advancement to many citizens who had previously been excluded from participation. The sophists offered to teach skills in leadership that would give their students advantages in the political arena. Plato has Protagoras profess to teach political science (politikē technē) to his students. Still, it is not clear how scientific political science was among the sophists. Plato himself has a great deal to say about political organization, especially in his Republic and Laws. But his political theory in the former is very idealized, and in the latter, more down-to-earth account, still requires an impossibly strong central government. Aristotle in his Politics offers a more general treatment of kinds of government and a more scientific analysis of the realities of ruling. Like Plato, he sees the state as the product of a natural social evolution. For Aristotle, man is a politikon zōion political animal—perhaps better rendered “a social animal” (Politics 1253a2-3). The state results spontaneously from an ever more inclusive integration of people, not from a social contract or an act of conquest. Above all, Aristotle sets off political science as a distinct study with its own principles and requirements.
- Rhetoric. The bread and butter of sophistic education was instruction in how to compose and deliver a speech. Success in this area could open doors to leadership in politics, business, and other areas. But teaching a practical skill is not the same as understanding the foundations and aims of the field. In his Rhetoric, Aristotle connects speech writing with psychology and other disciplines. To persuade others requires, among other things, understanding human thought, human society, and the environment.
- Literary Criticism. Aristotle did not invent literary criticism. We can see an instance of the practice in Plato’s Protagoras. But again, Aristotle focuses not on the details of a given poem or play, but on the general components of the literary experience. He founds his study on plot, character, and theme, in a general analysis that integrates crucial elements into a unified whole.
In all of these fields, Aristotle either invented the study himself or put it the path of a science (to use Kantian terms). He recognized principles unique to each area of study and made important contributions of his own. He did not invent the notion of research (Ionian historiē), but he raised it to a whole new level. He (presumably with help from his students) amassed data for each study—for instance, he collected hundreds of constitutions of Greek city states for his study of politics, hundreds of studies of animal specimens for his zoological studies, and hundreds of plays for his study of literature. He seems to have spent many hours observing the heavens by night (he recorded an occultation of Mars by the moon, On the Heavens 292a3-6) and collecting specimens by day for his dissections.
But more than conducting his own heroic investigations, he saw the need for identifying distinct areas of investigation. Besides the philosophy of science, he recognized a philosophy of sciences. The school he founded in Athens, the Lyceum, made important contributions to science. Eventually, however, it was eclipsed by the revival of Platonism and a renewed emphasis on the spiritual side of things, in the third century CE.
At the end of the ancient world, barbarians overran much of Europe and put an end to classical culture as we know it. Plato’s writings disappeared from western Europe, all but half of one dialogue, the Timaeus. And Aristotle’s writings disappeared likewise, all but a few short treatises. In 1075 CE, Aristotelian texts were discovered, translated into Arabic in a library in Toledo, Spain. Eager for more texts, Christian scholars of the 12th and 13th centuries got hold first of Arabic translations of his work, then of Greek copies from the Byzantine Empire, and rendered them into Latin. Thomas Aquinas defended Aristotle’s work as offering the best foundation for Christian theology (despite his being a pagan with some decidedly un-Christian ideas). With the rise of universities in western Europe as centers of Christian education, Aristotle became the foundation of many curricula. And the idea of a multitude of independent sciences returned to the world as an inspiration for renewed empirical research projects into the natural world.