Plato

Plato

The scion of a distinguished family, Plato was related to two members of the Thirty, the oligarchical government that took over after Athens was defeated by Sparta in 404 BC. He considered joining the junta, but fortunately did not. He was soon appalled by their excesses and by their treatment of his mentor, Socrates. He later spent much of his energy developing a theory of the ideal state.

Syracuse

Plato made three voyages to the Greek city Syracuse on the island of Sicily, the first time when he was about forty years old; the second time when he was about sixty; and the third time when he was about sixty-six. The first time he met the powerful and ruthless tyrant, Dionysius, and also his young son-in-law Dion, who became Plato's devoted disciple. The second time he came after the death of the tyrant at the invitation of Dion, to educate the tyrant's son and heir, Dionysius II. The new ruler proved to be erratic and unteachable, and exiled Dion for his trouble. Plato made his third visit reluctantly, to try to reconcile the young ruler and Dion, but that effort ended in disaster. Dion later overthrew Dionysius II but was assassinated. Plato's efforts to bring to pass a philosophical kingdom failed miserably. (Photo credit: Angelo Bonomo: Syracuse with Mount Etna in the background. cc-by-2.0, attribution, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=23148161)

The Academy

After his first visit to Syracuse, Plato organized a school where intellectuals could gather and share knowledge and pursue researches. It met at a gymnasium to the north of Athens, the Academy. There were one or two schools of oratory operating in Athens before Plato's school, but none of them had the prestige or influence of Plato's association. Farmers left their plows to attend, while women disguised themselves as men to participate. The greatest minds of the Greek world gathered to Athens to study mathematics, science, and philosophy. While there were no formal courses of study or degrees awarded, the Academy was the closest the ancient world came to having a university, and it became the model for other philosophical schools, several of which would be founded later in Athens.

Introduction

PLATO lived from about 427 to 347 BC in Athens.  He came from a prominent family and had all the advantages of money and connections.  Yet he became a follower of Socrates, a man from the working class who went around barefoot in a ragged cloak.  He tells us in his biographical Seventh Letter (a work whose authenticity has often been challenged, but which is very well-informed and now has the support of stylometric science behind it) that he considered joining the oligarchical government of the Thirty when the replaced the democracy in 404 BC.  He soon saw, as did everyone who stayed in Athens, that they were a vicious, self-serving junta.  Socrates refused to do their bidding and risked his life.  The Thirty were overthrown by a popular uprising.  

Socrates was later put to death for ostensibly religious reasons, but really for political reasons that motivated almost all trials in Athens.  Plato joined a number of the “Socratics,” the followers of Socrates, in publishing dialogues portraying Socrates as he was and vindicating him as a virtuous man seeking the good of Athens.  Plato was such a good writer that his dialogues became the literature of the fourth century. 

Plato made a voyage to southern Italy and Sicily when he was about forty years old, apparently to learn more about the Pythagorean philosophers who lived there.  He became friends with the leading Pythagorean philosopher and statesman Archytas, and also the powerful and ruthless tyrant of Syracuse, Dionysius and his brother-in-law Dion, who became a devoted follower of Plato.  Plato began to go beyond the ethical theories of Socrates, introducing the Pythagorean notions of immortality of soul (which Socrates was agnostic about) and reincarnation, as well as his own notion of ideal Forms such as the Forms of Justice and Equality, which gave their character to changeable things in this world.  

On returning to Athens, Plato founded his Academy, which provided a forum for intellectual from throughout the Greek world, and a kind of proto-university (but without degrees or formal courses of study).  Having defended the memory of Socrates in his early dialogues, he wrote his middle-period dialogues (see introduction to Socrates), in which he made Socrates a mouthpiece for his own theories of knowledge and reality (topics that Socrates did not study).  He also applied his theories to politics, developing the notion of an ideal state in his long dialogue The Republic, along with theories of education of the philosopher-kings he wanted to rule the state, psychology, theology, aesthetics, and other topics.

In his old age, he was invited back to Syracuse by his friend and disciple Dion, who hoped to instill philosophy in the new tyrant, Dionysius II, and create a more rational and perhaps ideal state.  But alas, the young tyrant sided with the enemies of Dion and had him exiled, leaving Plato in an awkward position of being dependent on an unstable dictator.  He finally was able to return home, only to be pressured to return a few years later to reconcile Dionysius II with Dion.  That project was another disaster, with the tyrant constantly manipulating the situation for his advantage.  Again, Plato was barely able to get away.  A few years later Dion led a revolt against the tyrant, which forced Dionysius II to flee.  But Dion was assassinated by a former member of Plato’s Academy in an embarrassing contretemps. 

Plato can be seen as the man who, more than any other, vindicated Socrates to the world.  Inspired by Socrates’ moral philosophy, he built a framework to buttress ethics through theories of knowledge (the Theory of Recollection), reality (the Theory of Forms), psychology (Immortality of Soul, Reincarnation, Tripartite Soul), politics (the Ideal State, different forms of government), and even natural science (Creationism, the centrifocal cosmos).  He provide perhaps the first comprehensive philosophical theory. 

Recent Discussions

21.3 What Is Knowledge?

The dialogue that constitutes the sequel to the Parmenides is the Theaetetus.  It begins with a short introduction in which Euclides of Megara, the philosopher who had hosted the Socratics in a retreat after the death of Socrates (see above, ch. 6.1*), shares with his friend and countryman Terpsion a

Read More »

21.2 From Heraclitus to Plato

We are confronted with a developmental story that sounds very Hegelian.  First there was Heraclitus, who said all was flux.  Then there was Parmenides, who said all was at rest.  Then there was Plato, who said that the sensible world was flux, the world of Forms was at rest, and

Read More »

21.1 Plato and Heraclitus

In the Parmenides, Plato brought his mentor and hero Socrates face to face with Parmenides of Elea, the most imposing and reverend figure of early Greek philosophy.  He also introduced Parmenides’ most famous student, Zeno of Elea.  Parmenides and his followers were famous for declaring that there is no change:

Read More »

20.10 The Moral of the Story

So what are we supposed to learn from the attacks on the Theory of Forms in the first half of the Parmenides and the litany of arguments in the second half?              According to Samuel Rickless, in his intensive study of the dialogue, we are to learn that four of

Read More »

20.9 Aristotle on the Third Man

There is something very Aristotelian about the Third Man Argument—including the name.  For Aristotle (but not Plato), the most real things are biological specimens, like Man (in the sense of a human being, member of the species Home sapiens).  For Plato a non-substantial property like Largeness will do quite well

Read More »

20.8 The Third Man Argument

The Parmenides is an unprecedented, baffling, and even bizarre dialogue.  Two towering philosophical figures of yesteryear come to town, meet the young and up-and-coming Socrates, listen to him expound his theory of forms; Parmenides criticizes it, causing Socrates to despair; he then encourages him not to lose heart, but hone

Read More »