21.8 Knowledge as True Judgment with an Account
Now Theaetetus remembers hearing someone say that knowledge is true judgment with an account (logos). According to his source, things that lacked an account were not knowable. Socrates offers a “dream” to help clarify the proposed definition. “I think I have heard people saying that the first components, like elements
21.7 Knowledge as True Judgment
Overwhelmed by objections to the thesis that knowledge is perception, Theaetetus abandons it. Socrates asks him for another definition. He replies, it consists of judging (doxazein). Socrates plods him to be more specific. Theaetetus observes that there is false as well as true judgment, so “True judgment would have to
21.6 Heraclitus Redivivus
Plato allowed Protagoras to defend himself against a too-hasty refutation. He does not offer the same opportunity to Heraclitus. But perhaps we should. Plato famously reported, “Heraclitus, I believe, says that all things pass and nothing stays, and comparing existing things to the flow of a river [potamou rhoēi],
21.4 Knowledge as Perception and Man as the Meature
At this point in the dialogue, we have Theaetetus’ definition of knowledge, that it is sense perception, buttressed by the alleged insight of Protagoras that man is the measure of all things, and by the alleged insight of Heraclitus that everything is in flux. Now Socrates raises some preliminary objections
21.3 What Is Knowledge?
The dialogue that constitutes the sequel to the Parmenides is the Theaetetus. It begins with a short introduction in which Euclides of Megara, the philosopher who had hosted the Socratics in a retreat after the death of Socrates (see above, ch. 6.1*), shares with his friend and countryman Terpsion a
21.2 From Heraclitus to Plato
We are confronted with a developmental story that sounds very Hegelian. First there was Heraclitus, who said all was flux. Then there was Parmenides, who said all was at rest. Then there was Plato, who said that the sensible world was flux, the world of Forms was at rest, and