15.4 Laches and Nicias On and Off the Battlefield

Laches had a distinguished military career before and after the meeting portrayed by Plato.  In 427, previous to the time of the encounter with Socrates, Laches, along with a colleague Charoedes, commanded a fleet of twenty ships that sailed to Sicily in response to the Leontine embassy Gorgias participated in (ch. 10*).[22]  When Charoedes died in battle, Laches became the sole commander of the force.  In 426 he won a victory against the city of Messene, causing that city to come over to the Athenian side and giving the Athenians control of the straits of Messene.[23]  Thereafter, Laches made an unsuccessful attack on the town of Inessa and raided Locris.[24] 

In 422, after the time of the meeting with Socrates, Cleon accused Laches of embezzling money during the Sicilian campaign, in an attempt to discredit him.  It was a typical political trial, disguised as something else: Cleon was the leader of the pro-war faction, Laches a co-leader, together with Nicias, of the peace faction.[25]  Aristophanes made fun of the trial in The Wasps, in which several dogs accuse another dog of stealing a Sicilian cheese.[26]  Laches was acquitted, as was Aristophanes’ canine defendant.  Three years after the Peace of Nicias, which he helped broker,[27] in 418, Laches was killed at the battle of Mantinea in the Peloponnesus.[28]

            As to Nicias, we will meet him again (ch. 17*).  His later story may affect our understanding of Plato’s dialogue.  As for Lysimachus’ son Aristides, we are told that he followed Socrates for a time with beneficial results, but then fell into bad company, while Melesias’ son Thucydides also followed Socrates.[29] 

            What is clear, in any case, is that Socrates exemplified courage—and wisdom—on the battlefield and off.


[22].Thucydides 3.86; Diodorus Siculus 12.53-54.

[23].Thucydides 3.90.

[24].Thucydides 3.103.

[25].In particular, Laches had proposed the one-year truce that Brasidas violated; see n. 1* above.

[26].Aristophanes Wasps 836-43, 891-997.

[27].Thucydides 5.19.2.

[28].Thucydides 5.74.3, 5.61.1.

[29]. Plato Theaetetus 150e-151a; in a later, more apocryphal version, Thucydides son of Melesias also associated with Socrates: ps.Plato Theages 130a-e.  See Nails 2002:49-50, 292.